Let's take another look


iconInstant Replay is coming to College Football.

"The response to video replay nationally and in the Big Ten was overwhelmingly positive," said Chuck Broyles, the coach at Pittsburg State and chairman of the rules committee. "When we have the ability to correct a potentially game-changing error, and we have the technology to do so, we feel this improves the fairness of the game and directly improves the student-athlete experience."
Nobody wants to lose on a game changing play, but football purists (such as myself) will undoubtedly cringe at the thought. First of all, the NFL has had countless iterations of instant replay, none of which seemed to work very well. At least the current NFL system minimizes the delay of the game.

But another untold problem of instant replay is that it tends to degrade the quality of officiating. In the NFL, the number of challenges seems to be increasing. Although bad calls were sometimes a problem, it was nowhere near the 3 or 4 calls per game, which it seems like are challenged now-a-days.

I'm sure many will disagree, but then again I think the Designated Hitter should be outlawed, and the inventor Astroturf drawn and quartered.


Category:  Sports
Comments (2)      top   link me

Comments

I'm with you on Astroturf ("rug burn" should not be a term heard in conjuction with a sporting event), but I must admit to having mixed feelings on the DH issue. I agree that there would be fewer beanballs wars if ptichers had to bat in the AL, but do we really want to watch someone with a lifetime average of .047 flailing away at a 74 MPH curveball? I live in an NL city, but I still cringe every time I see Jose Lima come to the plate.

Posted by: Jack Cluth at February 11, 2005 8:49 AM

I agree with all three of your last observations. I ALSO notice late whistles in the NFL now (I'm not going to call it sloppy officiating, but I Do see what's happening--- they don't blow the play dead when they should because they can review it later) and I'm not sure that's good for the game.

What price are we willing to pay for "zero defects" in officiating?

Posted by: Acidman at February 13, 2005 11:14 PM

(c) Ravenwood and Associates, 1990 - 2014

About Ravenwood
Libertarianism
Libertarian Quiz
Secrets o' the Universe
Email Ravenwood

reading
<Blogroll Me>
/images/buttons/ru-button-r.gif

Bitch Girls
Bogie Blog
Countertop Chronicles
DC Thornton
Dean's World
Dumb Criminals
Dustbury
Gallery Clastic
Geek with a .45
Gut Rumbles
Hokie Pundit
Joanie
Lone Star Times
Other Side of Kim
Right Wing News
Say Uncle
Scrappleface
Silflay Hraka
Smallest Minority
The Command Post
Venomous Kate
VRWC


FemmeBloggers


archives

search the universe



rings etc

Gun Blogs


rss feeds
[All Versions]
[PDA Version]
[Non-CSS Version]
XML 0.91
RSS 1.0 (blurb)
RSS 2.0 (full feed)
 

credits
Design by:

Powered by: Movable Type 3.34
Encryption by: Deltus
Hosted by: Bluehost

Ravenwood's Universe:
Established 1990

Odometer

OdometerOdometerOdometerOdometerOdometer